Burrata and mozzarella are both fresh Italian cheeses made from cow’s or buffalo’s milk, but they are not the same thing. The key difference is what’s inside: mozzarella is solid throughout, while burrata has a soft, creamy filling made from fresh cream and shredded curd. That one difference changes everything about how they taste, how you use them, and how long they last. Below, we answer the most common questions about these two beloved Italian cheeses side by side.
At Casa di David, we have been serving authentic Italian ingredients for 50 years, and burrata and mozzarella both have a place on our table. Here is everything you need to know about them.
How is burrata actually made differently from mozzarella?
Mozzarella is made by heating fresh curd in hot water or whey, then stretching and kneading it until it becomes smooth and elastic. It is then shaped into balls and cooled in brine. Burrata starts the same way, but instead of being shaped into a solid ball, the fresh mozzarella is formed into a pouch and filled with stracciatella, a mixture of shredded mozzarella curd and fresh cream, before being sealed shut.
The result is a cheese with two distinct textures in one: a firm, thin outer shell of mozzarella and a rich, loose, creamy interior. When you cut into burrata, the filling spills out. That contrast is the whole point. Mozzarella, by comparison, has a consistent texture from outside to inside: smooth, springy, and mild throughout.
Both cheeses belong to the pasta filata family, meaning they are made using the stretched-curd method. Burrata originates from the Puglia region in southern Italy and was first made in the early 20th century as a way to use leftover cream and curd scraps. Mozzarella has a much longer history, with roots in the Campania region going back several centuries.
What does burrata taste like compared to mozzarella?
Burrata tastes richer, creamier, and more indulgent than mozzarella. The outer shell has the mild, milky flavour of fresh mozzarella, but the interior is buttery and soft, with a slight tang from the cream. Mozzarella on its own is clean and delicate in flavour, with a light saltiness and a fresh, milky quality that does not overpower other ingredients.
If mozzarella is the quiet, reliable base of a dish, burrata is the moment of richness that makes people pause. The filling has a looser, almost pourable consistency when the cheese is at room temperature, which makes it feel luxurious without being heavy. Both cheeses are mild enough to pair well with bold flavours like tomato, basil, olive oil, and cured meats.
Are burrata and mozzarella made from the same milk?
Both burrata and mozzarella can be made from cow’s milk or buffalo’s milk, so the milk type is not what sets them apart. The most celebrated version of mozzarella is mozzarella di bufala campana, made from the milk of Italian water buffalo and protected by a DOP designation. Burrata is most commonly made from cow’s milk, though buffalo milk versions also exist.
Buffalo milk produces a richer, slightly tangier cheese with a higher fat content than cow’s milk. Cow’s milk versions are milder and more widely available. When you are buying either cheese, checking the milk source on the label gives you a good indication of the flavour intensity and richness you can expect.
Which cheese works better for cooking versus eating fresh?
Mozzarella is the better choice for cooking, while burrata is best eaten fresh and unheated. Mozzarella melts evenly and predictably, which is why it is the standard cheese for pizza, baked pasta, and gratins. Its lower moisture content in the low-moisture variety makes it ideal for high-heat cooking without releasing too much liquid.
Burrata does not hold up well to heat. The creamy filling breaks down and loses its texture when warmed, which removes the very quality that makes it special. It is best served at room temperature, drizzled with good olive oil, with a pinch of sea salt and some crusty bread alongside it. Warm it gently at most: never bake it.
- Mozzarella works well for: pizza, lasagne, baked dishes, panini, and melted toppings
- Burrata works well for: antipasto plates, fresh salads, bruschetta, and serving alongside roasted vegetables or cured meats
- Both work well for: caprese-style dishes, though burrata gives a richer result
How long does each cheese stay fresh?
Fresh mozzarella typically stays good for five to seven days when stored in its brine in the refrigerator. Burrata is more delicate and is best eaten within one to two days of purchase, ideally on the day you buy it. The fresh cream filling makes burrata particularly perishable, and the quality drops noticeably after the first day.
Both cheeses should be stored in the refrigerator but brought to room temperature before serving. Cold dulls the flavour and firms up the texture. Give mozzarella about 20 minutes out of the fridge, and burrata a similar amount of time. Once you have opened either cheese, consume it the same day for the best experience.
Is burrata more expensive than mozzarella, and why?
Yes, burrata is generally more expensive than mozzarella. The price difference comes down to the additional labour and ingredients involved in making it. Burrata requires the extra step of filling each pouch by hand with fresh cream and shredded curd, which makes it more time-consuming to produce. It is also more perishable, which means higher wastage and more careful handling throughout the supply chain.
Good quality fresh mozzarella, particularly mozzarella di bufala, is also not cheap, but burrata tends to sit at a higher price point for an equivalent weight. When you are buying either cheese, freshness and provenance matter more than price alone. Imported Italian burrata or mozzarella made with quality milk will always outperform a cheaper, mass-produced version.
Can you substitute burrata for mozzarella in a recipe?
You can substitute burrata for mozzarella in some recipes, but not all. For cold dishes and antipasto, burrata is a direct upgrade: it adds richness and a more dramatic presentation. For cooked dishes like pizza or baked pasta, burrata is not a suitable substitute because the filling does not melt properly and the texture will be lost.
- Check whether the recipe involves heat. If yes, stick with mozzarella.
- Consider the texture balance. Burrata is softer and wetter, which can make some dishes feel heavy.
- Adjust other ingredients if needed. Burrata is richer, so you may want less olive oil or cream elsewhere in the dish.
- Serve burrata at the end. If you want a burrata element in a warm dish, add it after cooking as a topping rather than cooking it directly.
The substitution works best when the cheese is the centrepiece of the dish rather than a background ingredient. A simple plate of ripe tomatoes with good olive oil becomes something memorable with burrata. The same dish with mozzarella is lovely but more understated.
How Casa di David brings Italian cheese to the table
At Casa di David, Italian cheese is not an afterthought. It is part of how we cook and how we think about food. Our kitchen uses quality Italian ingredients because that is what La Cucina Italiana Originale requires, and fresh, authentic cheese is central to that. Whether it appears on an antipasto plate, inside a handmade pasta, or alongside our focaccia from the deli next door, we treat it with the respect it deserves.
- Antipasto and starter dishes that let fresh Italian cheese speak for itself
- Handmade pastas and wood-fired pizzas using quality mozzarella as it was meant to be used
- A menu rooted in regional Italian tradition, updated daily with fresh seasonal ingredients
- A warm, lively atmosphere on the Singel canal in the heart of Amsterdam
- Open daily from 5 PM, with weekend lunch from 12:30 PM
If reading about burrata and mozzarella has made you hungry for the real thing, we would love to have you at the table. Book a table at Casa di David and come taste what 50 years of Italian cooking in Amsterdam actually feels like. Take a look at our full menu to see what is waiting for you.